• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Core Principles of Responsible AI
    • Accountability
    • Fairness
    • Privacy
    • Safety and Security
    • Sustainability
    • Transparency
  • Special Topics
    • AI in Industry
    • Ethical Implications
    • Human-Centered Design
    • Regulatory Landscape
    • Technical Methods
  • Living Dictionary
  • State of AI Ethics
  • AI Ethics Brief
  • šŸ‡«šŸ‡·
Montreal AI Ethics Institute

Montreal AI Ethics Institute

Democratizing AI ethics literacy

Anthropomorphism and the Social Robot

January 12, 2022

šŸ”¬ Research summary by Connor Wright, our Partnerships Manager.

[Original paper by Brian R. Duffy]


Overview: Have you ever found a technology too human for your liking? The benefit of utilising anthropomorphism to involve AI in our lives is a popular strategy. Yet, its success depends on how well the balance between too much and too little is achieved.


Introduction

Anthropomorphism is the sure-fire way to integrate AI (social robots) into our lives. Construed in this way, familiarity with AI and the human interaction this brings about is one of the benefits of anthropomorphism. In this way, anthropomorphism can act as the medium between humans and AI. However, this can go too far, with too much anthropomorphisation proving counterproductive. Hence, exploring AI integration into our lives becomes a game of balance.

Key Insights

Integrating AI into our lives

Anthropomorphism is the most obvious way to integrate robots into our life. It harnesses the familiarity of human movement, allowing us to better rationalise and relate to the AI’s behaviour. In this way, we are more likely to interact with the technology, deepening its involvement in human lives. Hence, rather than being seen as an endeavour to design humanoid robots, anthropomorphism aims to integrate AI into our society successfully.

As a result, social acceptance of the technology is also necessary. Familiarity with an AI through interaction is part of it, but so too is the emotional functionality of the AI. It is a tricky path to tread in terms of appropriately portraying that the AI has emotions, but it can prove pivotal in solidifying the social acceptance of the robot. As shown in the case of Phineas Gage, a lack of appropriate emotional response when interacting with humans makes it impossible to fit in. an emotionless robot also plays into the traditional AI-fear of killer robots.

Questions of designing social robots need to consider how the robots are not to seem fearsome to a human. For the ā€œharmonious coexistenceā€ (p.g 186) to be established, the aforementioned familiarity with the technology can lend a hand. In this way, anthropomorphism can act as a medium for human-AI interaction.

Anthropomorphism as a medium

Given the use of ā€˜social’ in ā€˜social robots’, they are viewed as ā€œthe interface between man and technologyā€ (p.g 178), proving the first step in preventing seeing machines as purely tools and instead fellow society members. Here, anthropomorphism is the ā€œlanguageā€ (p.g 181) to facilitate interaction between AI and humans.

An interesting question is whether this medium allows humans to believe they are interacting with an ā€˜intelligent’ entity. Here, on the strong AI view, the technology can be intelligent once it replicates the biological mechanisms of the human brain. On the other hand, the weak AI view sees ā€˜artificial intelligence’ as an oxymoron, stating how AI can only ever display signs of intelligence (good enough to pass the historic Turing Test). No matter which view you subscribe to, anthropomorphism is not a way to seek out human approval of intelligence but rather to encourage human interaction.

However, with this aim in mind, an AI can be too anthropomorphic.

An AI can be too anthropomorphic

Duffy notes how ā€œSuccessful design in both software and robots in HCI needs to involve a balance of illusionā€ (p.g 178). Social robots thrive on creating the ā€œillusion of life and intelligenceā€ (p.g 178), and this illusion can sometimes be taken too far. Anthropomorphic AI can reach a point where its similarity to a human is unsettling and counter-productive. 

Exemplified in Mori’s Uncanny Valley, there comes the point where anthropomorphism leads to a severe drop in human interaction. In this way, an AI doesn’t need a full range of motion if it doesn’t help facilitate the production of its desired output.

Between the lines

I am in total agreement that anthropomorphism can reach a sub-optimal point. It can become an obsession for designers in the social robot arena, often obscuring the main driving force of the technique, soliciting human interaction. Hence, I love the analogy offered by Duffy that when you employ anthropomorphism, you are ā€œnot trying to replicate a bird to fly but rather recognising those qualities that lead to the invention of the plane.ā€ (p.g 183). Here, anthropomorphism is all about learning and employing the qualities of what makes good interaction, rather than just recreating a human.

Want quick summaries of the latest research & reporting in AI ethics delivered to your inbox? Subscribe to the AI Ethics Brief. We publish bi-weekly.

Primary Sidebar

šŸ” SEARCH

Spotlight

AI Policy Corner: The Kenya National AI Strategy

AI Policy Corner: New York City Local Law 144

Canada’s Minister of AI and Digital Innovation is a Historic First. Here’s What We Recommend.

Am I Literate? Redefining Literacy in the Age of Artificial Intelligence

AI Policy Corner: The Texas Responsible AI Governance Act

related posts

  • The E.U.’s Artificial Intelligence Act: An Ordoliberal Assessment

    The E.U.’s Artificial Intelligence Act: An Ordoliberal Assessment

  • Research summary: Using Multimodal Sensing to Improve Awareness in Human-AI Interaction

    Research summary: Using Multimodal Sensing to Improve Awareness in Human-AI Interaction

  • Broadening the Algorithm Auditing Lens to Investigate Targeted Advertising

    Broadening the Algorithm Auditing Lens to Investigate Targeted Advertising

  • The Watsons Meet Watson: A Call for Carative AI

    The Watsons Meet Watson: A Call for Carative AI

  • Mind your Language (Model): Fact-Checking LLMs and their Role in NLP Research and Practice

    Mind your Language (Model): Fact-Checking LLMs and their Role in NLP Research and Practice

  • Privacy Limitations Of Interest-based Advertising On The Web: A Post-mortem Empirical Analysis Of Go...

    Privacy Limitations Of Interest-based Advertising On The Web: A Post-mortem Empirical Analysis Of Go...

  • Research summary: Algorithmic Colonization of Africa

    Research summary: Algorithmic Colonization of Africa

  • Fair Interpretable Representation Learning with Correction Vectors

    Fair Interpretable Representation Learning with Correction Vectors

  • Visions of Artificial Intelligence and Robots in Science Fiction: a computational analysis

    Visions of Artificial Intelligence and Robots in Science Fiction: a computational analysis

  • Responsible Use of Technology: The IBM Case Study

    Responsible Use of Technology: The IBM Case Study

Partners

  • Ā 
    U.S. Artificial Intelligence Safety Institute Consortium (AISIC) at NIST

  • Partnership on AI

  • The LF AI & Data Foundation

  • The AI Alliance

Footer

Categories


• Blog
• Research Summaries
• Columns
• Core Principles of Responsible AI
• Special Topics

Signature Content


• The State Of AI Ethics

• The Living Dictionary

• The AI Ethics Brief

Learn More


• About

• Open Access Policy

• Contributions Policy

• Editorial Stance on AI Tools

• Press

• Donate

• Contact

The AI Ethics Brief (bi-weekly newsletter)

About Us


Founded in 2018, the Montreal AI Ethics Institute (MAIEI) is an international non-profit organization equipping citizens concerned about artificial intelligence and its impact on society to take action.


Archive

  • Ā© MONTREAL AI ETHICS INSTITUTE. All rights reserved 2024.
  • This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
  • Learn more about our open access policy here.
  • Creative Commons License

    Save hours of work and stay on top of Responsible AI research and reporting with our bi-weekly email newsletter.